To celebrate one year of Rotten Rentals (our online shop) we are announcing 7 prizes over 7 days.

Rotten Rentals combine the sense of nostalgia we use to get from going to our local video shop and renting our favorite horror and sci-fi films on VHS with vintage trading cards we use to collect as kids. Mash the two together and you have Rotten Rentals. VHS cases with throwback artwork that contain vintage trading cards, mini zombie figures, zombie tarot cards, creepy crawlies, buttons, stickers and more!

To celebrate our first year online we want to give a bigfoot sized THANK YOU to all of our loyal customers who have helped make our first year amazing!

Tell us your favorite serial killer movie of all-time and why in the comment section below. Please include your email address so we can contact you if you win! A winner will be randomly selected on December 16th, 2014. You must be 18 years old to enter. We will only ship within the U.S. at this time. Good luck and Stay Rotten!



– Vintage Packs of Cards
– Mini Zombie Figure
– Zombie Tarot Card
- Mini SOTL Quad Poster
– and more!
*does not include a “great big fat person” or lotion 🙁




  • Thomas Townsend

    “Gutterballs”!! It’s great gory & sleazy fun.

  • Johnny Tellez

    Se7en, that is just one perfect film altogether.

  • Meredith Ries

    Gotta be Psycho.

  • Darc_Ecko

    Helter Skelter (1976)

  • Tasha Holmes-French

    Seven! I loved the way they addressed the seven deadly sins and the ending was crazy!!!!

  • Nick

    The Collection I love both of these movies but I really enjoyed this one

  • Dustin Bramlett

    The Texas Chainsaw Massacre (74)

  • Phil Truman

    Michael Myers.

  • Stefanie Holmes

    Friday the 13th….Vorhees just has a way with the ladies

  • Remy Dawn

    The Bone Collector. I love the way the killer left clues at each “drop” so that the cops could try to find him. It was a big game of cat and mouse to him. Also how his victims were random. He didn’t have a type like some killers do.

  • Jacqueline Smith

    From Hell gets my vote, mainly because it’s based on true events# Jack the Ripper not to mention all the gory scenes.

  • Manny Granillo

    Kyung-chul from I Saw The Devil. The bastard struck fear into other serial killers, that’s how hardcore he was. He tortured, desecrated, dismembered, and slashed his victims into pieces and felt no remorse about it. When he actually confronts two other killers by sheer coincidence, he brings them both down even with a broken arm. Even until the very end he remained stubborn and merciless. Truly a fantastic killer.

  • bill norris

    Silence of the Lambs…. some scenes in that movie still give me the creeps….but not enough to stop watching. Great acting and a creepy story drags me in every time.

  • Drew Forshey

    Theodore Robert “Ted” Bundy was an American
    serial killer, kidnapper, rapist, and necrophile who assaulted and
    murdered numerous young women and girls during the 1970s and possibly
    earlier. Shortly before his execution, after more than a decade of
    denials, he confessed to 30 homicides committed in seven states between
    1974 and 1978. The true victim count remains unknown, and could be much

  • Stephen Gilliam

    “Night watch”
    Nick Nolte scares me regardless if he’s playing a serial killer. Just anticipating that morgue light coming on killed me.

  • Leon Michael Hernandez

    I really love the movie Copycat. I have a serious thing for Sigourney Weaver.

  • David Keel

    American Psycho. It had a lot of humor and an over the top performance by Christian Bale. dak02 (at) Hotmail (dot) com

    • KC Canton

      Congrats, David! You have won our Rotten Rentals Silence of the Lambs VHS Pack! Please send your mailing address to within 3 days to claim your prize!